Your Local Insurance Agency in Cedarville, Michigan

Big Enough to Serve, Small Enough to Care

At Islands Insurance Center, we’re more than an insurance agency — we’re part of the community. Rooted in Cedarville and throughout Michigan. Our mission is simple: protect what matters most to you with personalized coverage and neighborly service.

Insurance Built on Trust, Backed by Experience

For more than a decade, Islands Insurance Center has been helping families, individuals, and businesses across Michigan navigate the complex world of insurance. Our mission is to simplify coverage, communicate clearly, and deliver policies that fit your life — not just a template.

Our mission

“At Islands Insurance Center, our mission is to protect what matters most to our neighbors across Cedarville, the Les Cheneaux Islands, and all of Michigan. We provide personalized insurance solutions built on trust, strengthened by experience, and delivered with clear communication. As a community-rooted agency, we’re committed to treating every client like family while offering the protection and peace of mind they deserve.”

Built on Trust. Backed by Experience. 


Two hands in a handshake, a symbol of agreement.

Trust

We put people first and stand by our word.

Document with a seal, indicating a certificate or award.

Experience

Years of knowledge in both personal and commercial insurance.

Black speech bubble icon with three dots.

Communication

Quick, clear responses so you’re never left waiting.

Three people, one with radiating lines above head, suggesting a brilliant idea or leader.

Community

Rooted in Cedarville, serving the Eastern Upper Peninsula with pride.

The Strength of Islands Insurance Center

Allyson Coveyou

Personal Insurance Specialist

& Agent

Allyson combines knowledge and care to help clients find the right personal insurance solutions with confidence and ease.

Kathy Martin

Commercial Insurance Specialist

& Agent

Kathy combines expertise and commitment to help businesses protect what matters most, offering clear guidance and dependable solutions.

Stacey Massey

Personal Insurance Agent

Stacey brings experience, compassion, and practical knowledge to every client interaction, making personal insurance simple and stress-free.

Cayla Riordan

Licensed Agent

Cayla is dedicated to supporting individuals and families with thoughtful, personalized health and life insurance guidance that fits real needs.

Where We Work and Who We Serve

Rooted in Cedarville, Serving All of Michigan


From our office at 123 W. Highway M-134 in Cedarville, we serve families and businesses throughout the Les Cheneaux Islands, the Eastern Upper Peninsula, and across Michigan. Whether you live year-round, own a seasonal cottage, or operate a business anywhere in the state, Islands Insurance Center is here to provide personalized, reliable coverage.

Contact Us Today

Insurance, The Neighborly Way

 At Islands Insurance Center, we combine the resources of a full-service Michigan insurance agency with the warmth of a local neighbor. When you work with us, you’re more than a policy — you’re part of the community we proudly serve.